These questions are central to the study of jurisprudence, and are critically examined in this book. Buy legal reasoning and legal theory, by neil maccormick, isbn 9780198763840, published by oxford university press from. Practical reasoning moves from reasons for action to choices and actions guided by those reasons. Feb 07, 2012 the nature of legal reasoning, and its relationship with reasoning, has long been a topic of importance for lawyers and legal scholars. The limits of the doctrine of nuisance 9 legal reasoning and the common law topic 4. Harts the concept of law, it claims that a theory of law like harts requires a particular theory of legal reasoning, or at least a theory of legal reasoning with some particular characteristics. Many of those who lament the extent to which theory is taught in the law school curriculum offer. A natural law theory is nothing other than a theory of good reasons for choice and action.
Neil maccormicks second thoughts on legal reasoning and. Legal reasoning and legal theory revisited springerlink. Persuasion and value in legal argument trevor benchcapon, katie atkinson and alison chorley, department of computer science, university of liverpool, liverpool l69 3bx, uk. Mar 20, 2020 llb entrance legal aptitude model question paper with answers. William blackstone asserted that it is an established rule to abide by former.
Reasoning with cases has been a primary focus of those working in ai and law who have attempted to model legal reasoning. Legal reasoning and legal theory oxford scholarship online. Since its first appearance in 1979, this work has establi. Natural law and legal reasoning john finnis i legal reasoning is, broadly speaking, practical reasoning. Lev, this i is an attempt to describe generally the process of legal reasoning in the field of case law and in the interpretation of statutes and of the constitution. Harts the concept of law, it claims that a theory of law like harts requires a particular theory of legal reasoning, or at least a theory of legal reasoning with some particular. Legal reasoning and legal theory oxford scholarship. The nature of legal reasoning, and its relationship with reasoning, has long been a topic of importance for lawyers and legal scholars. One of the most elaborate statements of natural law theory can be found in.
Natural law theory like legal positivism has appeared in a variety of forms and in many guises. This paper describes a model of legal reasoning and a logic for reasoning with rules, principles and goals that is especially suited to this model of legal reasoning. It frequently uses arguments that individuals do not employ, or that individuals employ in different ways. It stands firmly on its own as a contribution to an extensive. Maccormick provides a critical analysis of the dworkin position while also modifying harts. Pages in category legal reasoning the following 38 pages are in this category, out of 38 total. It is here that the court gives reason for its legal ruling, and it helps other courts, lawyers and judges to use and. While particularly relevant to the tasks of lawyers and judges, the requirements of legal reasoning also affect the legislator because addition of new rules or modification of existing ones needs to be. Legal reasoning and legal theory clarendon law series maccormick, neil on. Surely if anything matters in our attempts to understand law, it matters how judges do and or should decide cases, and that we have an account which adequately explains and can perhaps be used to guide or justify their activities. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. The theory of legal reasoning provides full weight to the operation of ajd and other standards in the legal process, and it shows that judges never have more than a limited discretion in hard or any other cases. Legal reasoning and legal theory by neil maccormick.
This study focuses on current jurisprudential debate between. Legal reasoning, the rule of law, and legal theory. A companion to philosophy of mind edited by samuel guttenplan 7. An explanation normally calls for some sort of causal account of a state of affairs. Legal reasoning and legal theory, by neil maccormick. Legal reasoning and legal theory clarendon law series. Legal reasoning in the case of a courts ruling is found in the discussion or analysis section of the judicial ruling. Learning legal reasoning, like learning to draw or paint, is a lifelong process. Legal reasoning, the rule of law, and theories of law one way of understanding postemas paper is as an effort to derive a theory of law from an analysis of legal reasoning.
Legal aptitude booklets legal reasoning orientation booklets 01, 02 and 03 are designed to provide readers a detailed introduction to indian law. Answering such questions is the business of a theory of legal reasoning. Theories of law natural law, legal positivism, the. Bertea, law and legal reasoning, northern ireland legal quarterly 59, 2008, 419 has espoused since his seminal work on legal reasoning, and this is the thesis by w hich a.
A companion to metaysics, ph second edition edited by jaegwon kim, ernest sosa and gary s. A theory of legal reasoning law, state, and practical reason neil maccormick. An introduction to legal reasoning chicago unbound. Levi really simplifies the science of legal reasoning in a nice easy to remember mantra of reasoning by example.
Legal reasoning and legal theory, by neil maccormick osgoode. Legal reasoning, legal theory and rights collected essays. In other words, legal reasoning may result in outcomes on which opinions differ, and it is for this reason that we have created courts to finally settle matters. Thomas aquinas and natural law theory natural law theory like legal positivism has appeared in a variety of forms and in many guises. Certainly, much of the paper is given over to a careful critique of. Chapter 1 argumentation in legal reasoning trevor benchcapon and henry prakken and giovanni sartor 1. Arguments from precedent and analogy are characteristic of legal reasoning.
A theory of legal reasoning and a logic to match1 jaap hage university of limburg, department of metajuridica, email. Formalism formalism is the application of an existing rule of law by its terms to a set of facts. Abstract this paper offers a diachronic reconstruction of maccormicks theory of law and legal argumentation. The same is true with law students and legal reasoning. Theories of law natural law, legal positivism, the morality. Goldings approach to the philosophy of law is that it contains conceptual and normative issues and in this volume logical issues in legal reasoning are examined, and. The late neil maccormick, formerly regius professor emeritus of public. Can legal decisions be justified by purely rational argument or are they ultimately determined by more. Legal reasoning and legal theory neil maccormick oxford. Since its first appearance in 1979, this work has established itself as a classic of legal philosophy.
The theory presented has been that the judicial duty to do justice according to law is a highly complex one. Roberts goulds essay 15 a classroom illustration of the analytic challenge 17 notes 22. Llb entrance legal aptitude model question paper with answers. Legal reasoning and legal theory revised a defence of the. Llb entrance legal aptitude model sample mock test question paper for 2020 exam, this llb entrance legal aptitude question are based on the syllabus but here some of the question may out of syllabus, just for your better exam preparation. It is important that the mechanism of legal reasoning should not be concealed by its pretense. The importance of his studies on practical reasoning in general and on.
The weak form is that even if moral theory can provide a solid basis for some moral judgments, it should not be used as a basis. A model of legal reasoning with cases incorporating. What is legal reasoning and how to apply it correctly. Natural law, legal positivism, the morality of law dworkins third theory of law legal realism and critical legal studies 1. This study focuses on current jurisprudential debate between the positivist views of herbert hart and the rights thesis of ronald dworkin. He tracks the development of case law, statutory interpretation, and constitutional law through this theory and provides a nice foundation for attacking legal problems. Legal aptitude answers are highlighted in bold letters questions from law entrance examinations conducted by various law schools and law colleges are included 1. Judges exercise power over our lives and, rightly so, we expect them to be just and objective in utilizing their power. The art of legal reasoning and the angst of judging northwestern. No mathematical agility or mechanical facility can replace the trained intuition that a legal professional needs.
The scientific study of law jurisprudence firs t started among a romans b greeks. The strong form, again, is that moral theory does not provide a solid basis for moral judgments. One of the most elaborate statements of natural law theory can be found in aquinas who distinguished four types of law. A companion to philosophy of law and legal theory, second edition edited by dennis patterson 9. Jan 01, 1978 legal reasoning and legal theory book. A theory of legal reasoning requires and is required by a theory of law. Neil maccormick description this is an interdisciplinary course drawing on material from the separate. Legal reasoning legal reasoning is the particular method of arguing used when applying legal rules to particular interactions among legal persons. Chapter 10 kelsens theory of law 155 chapter 11 the integrity and interpretation of law 173 chapter 12 social theory and law 191 chapter marx, marxism and marxist legal theory 215 chapter 14 liberalism and law 235 chapter 15 feminist legal theory 247 chapter 16 critical legal studies 267 chapter 17 critical race theory 289. Many of those who lament the extent to which theory is taught in the law school curriculum offer explanations of the phenomenon that are often cynical. By analogy, a swimmer must learn at least a few basic strokes in order to survive in his new environment. The detailed contents for booklets are as mentioned below o introduction to legal reasoning o law and classification of laws o torts o contracts o criminal laws o constitutional law. Aug 05, 2016 legal reasoning is a method of thought and argument used by lawyers and judges when applying legal rules to specific interactions among legal persons. Can legal decisions be justified by purely rational argument or are they ultimately determined by more subjective influences.
The theory of legal reasoning provides full weight to the operation of principles and other standards in the legal process, and it shows that judges never have more than a limited discretion in hard or any other cases. Reasoning from either rules or principles must always involve some process of interpretation, so how does interpretive reasoning enter into the practical reason of law. This llb entrance legal aptitude paper will help all the students for their preparation, here the question type is mcq i. Interpretation and coherence in legal reasoning stanford. Legal theory definition of legal theory by medical. In this paper we put forward a formal model of reasoning with cases which captures many of the insights from that previous work. Legal problems 4 reading and understanding a case 4 legal reasoning 4 reasoning by analogy 4 inductive and deductive reasoning 5 case law 6 precedent in australian courts 7 judicial decision making 8 precedent in action. Legal reasoning as unique 5 beyond text and context 6 legal reasoning as art 7 legal reasoning as angst 8 developing and applying a model 9 notes 10 chapter one the challenge of calling balls and strikes. Legal reasoning differs in a number of ways from the sort of reasoning employed by individuals in their everyday lives. Once we have established that fact, we will abandon the traditional image of maccormick as the torchbearer of legal positivism. A justification normally calls for a defense of it.
A satisfactory theory of legal reasoning requires and is required by a satisfactory theory of law. If we had such a useful, normative method, it would surely be. The importance of his studies on practical reasoning in general and on legal reasoning and legal argumentation in particular, on legal institutionalism, on sovereignty, on the theory of rights and on the rule of law can hardly be exaggerated. Now, in making legal reasoning constitutive of the concept of law, the revised theory embraces a foundational element of nonpositivism, and that is the burden of my argument. Surely if anything matters in our attempts to understand law, it matters how judges do andor should decide cases, and that we have an account which adequately explains and can perhaps be used to guide or justify their activities. Judicial restraint and legal reasoning introduction the rule of law in common, statutory, and constitutional law is the law of judicial self restraint. It also recognizes that dworkins critique of positivists for having concentrated to excess. This book is a selection of articles and chapters published over martin goldings academic career. Legal reasoning and interpretation routledge encyclopedia.
Chapter 10 kelsens theory of law 155 chapter 11 the integrity and interpretation of law 173 chapter 12 social theory and law 191 chapter marx, marxism and marxist legal theory 215 chapter 14 liberalism and law 235 chapter 15 feminist legal theory 247 chapter 16. The first part describes a model of legal reasoning based on a twolayered view of the law. This article deals with the relation between a theory of law and a theory of legal reasoning. The role of analogical reasoning and its relationship with reasoning from. Legal theory publishes work on a broad range of topics, including but not limited to analytical jurisprudence, normative jurisprudence, policy analyses of legal institutions and. Legal theory draws contributions not only from academic law, but from a wide range of related disciplines in the humanities and social sciences, including philosophy, political science, economics, history and sociology. The subject of legal reasoning appears to occupy the more practical end of the spectrum of jurisprudential theorising. Assn legal writing directors 179, 181 2006 arguing that despite the theory of rhetoric as outcomedeterminative of legal decisionmaking, formal logic can be a possible. Buy legal reasoning and legal theory clarendon law series new ed by maccormick, neil isbn. A model of legal reasoning with cases incorporating theories. But it is also a topic with psychological implications, especially cognitive ones, and indeed most of the existing views about legal reasoning depend on psychological assumptions about the way in which ordinary.
868 1570 460 233 1405 472 1615 1132 1251 536 383 82 144 390 570 106 573 446 1250 1525 628 467 625 1101 1334 1373 353 174 1486 221